It is official, I am no longer mock trial sponsor. I resigned from the responsibility. It is going to be nice not having it hanging over my head. I’m going to miss it though.
What is mock trial? You work with a very small group of kids to prepare a court case designed by the Bar association. All depositions, evidence, and stipulations are provided. Students portray the witnesses and attorneys to present the case as it would be presented in court, creating questions and styling testimony. Attorneys from across the state are the judges for the case.
I have learned so much from working with mock trial. Law is actually a profession I could see myself pursuing. Much of mock trial is similar to debate. You have to know both sides of the case completely. One of the hardest concepts for students to grasp is never ask a question that you do not know the answer to. It is a very good rule to follow. If you already know the answer to the question then it is easy to catch the lie. When there is a lie then the one doing the questioning has to wonder why, and assume there must be something to lie about. This is where good attorneys will impeach the witness, or call him on his lie. The team last year was determined to catch their witness in a lie. A simple bending of truth or stumble on the question, an honest mistake, will not earn points for impeachment. It is the flat out lie that raises the eyebrow and encourages further questioning, resulting in more points for your team.
Students also had difficulty with objections. It takes strength to interrupt testimony, stand up, and state an objection. Students had to know how to recognize objectionable material, and how to express the grounds for objection. I can remember several times where an opposing attorney would stand up and object with, “OBJECTION your honor, that’s just not right” or “Objection, he’s making my witness look bad”. It is an amusing break in the courtroom drama when something like that happens. My students were taught to ALWAYS, at the least, state an objection in legal jargon…preferably the correct jargon.
Opening and closing statements were fun for the attorneys. It was their time to shine, and hopefully earn many points for their team. It is important to have a “hook” or theme to the statement. Maybe not in real life, I don’t know, but for our purposes it was. My favorite comes from a team in the Delta. The student stepped up to the podium, placed her notes, and then stepped from behind the podium. In a VERY theatrical and southern lawyer voice she proclaims, “LIES and DeceuP-shun”, and continues her opening. I have no idea what else she said because the first three words were such a shocking theatric, complete with hand motions. My first year as an assistant mock trial teacher sponsor there was a student who was not your ordinary high school student. He was as much, or more mature, than most adults I know. He was the student in khakis, dress shirt, and maybe a tie, walking around campus with a briefcase. (He broke his collar bone junior year and could no longer carry a backpack, so the briefcase became his storage for school work.) Great kid, really loved Shakespear. He was a thespian as well. The very last case we competed with he was able to slip in his Shakespear quotes. I’m not sure how much the judges liked it, but at that point we had so thoroughly impeached the opposing witnesses that it didn’t matter. The courtroom was at least entertained with his Shakespearean Matlock.
I’m going to miss it, but I am not going to miss the late nights in February scrambling for competition prep, case strategy, and all the logistical problems of taking students somewhere. My time was a fun learning process, but it is time to rest…






